On this page
To comp a wholesale deal, comp it twice. First find the after repair value (ARV) from renovated homes like yours that resold nearby. Then find the buyer price: what investors actually paid for similar homes, in similar condition, within about a mile in the last 12 months. The 70% rule turns the ARV into one number, and real investor purchases check it. Your highest offer is the buyer price minus your fee.
This guide is for wholesalers pricing deals on and off the MLS who want a number a cash buyer will actually pay.
Two numbers, not one
Most comping guides stop at the ARV. That's half the job. A wholesale deal sells to a cash buyer at today's condition, so the number that matters most is what cash buyers pay for houses like this one, not what a finished flip sells for.
| ARV comps | Buyer price comps | |
|---|---|---|
| What they are | Renovated homes that resold to retail buyers | Homes bought as is by investors, usually for cash |
| What they tell you | What the house is worth fixed up | What a cash buyer pays for it now |
| How you use them | 70% of ARV minus repairs | Price per square foot of those buys times your square footage |
| Where they come from | Sold listings with renovated photos | Below-market sales to LLCs, trusts or cash buyers, often off the MLS |
ARV path
- 1Renovated homes that resold nearby
- 2ARV about $235k
- 370% of ARV minus $25k repairs
$139.5k
Buyer price path
- 1Homes investors bought as is nearby
- 2About $95 to $100 a square foot
- 3Times 1,450 square feet
$138k to $145k
Buyer price about $140k, minus a $10k fee = highest offer about $130k
When the two numbers land close together, you can price with confidence. When they're far apart, one of your comp sets is wrong, and it's worth finding out which before you send an offer.
Step 1: Set the box
Before you look at a single sale, decide what counts. These are the limits I use:
- Distance: within 1 mile is best. Past 2 miles, I don't use it.
- Time: the last 12 months. A sale from two years ago is a different market.
- Same kind of house: same property type, similar square footage, beds within one. A sale with one more bedroom can count if your house has the square footage to add one.
- Same street feel: don't cross a highway, a railroad or a school boundary into a different neighborhood.
If the box gives you fewer than three sales, widen the time window before you widen the distance.
Step 2: Find the ARV from renovated resales
Pull the sold homes in your box and open the photos. You're looking for homes that were fully renovated when they sold: new kitchen, new floors, new paint, updated baths. Aim for three to six. If only one true flip sold, it's still the comp that sets your ARV; base it on that sale and use the rest as support.
Adjust for what the comp has that yours doesn't:
- A garage, a bigger lot or an in-ground pool pushes the comp's price up, so your ARV comes in lower.
- An above-ground pool isn't a pool for comping.
- A clean but dated house that sold a little under your ARV is a useful check that you're not too high.
Then run the quick version: 70% of the ARV minus repairs. The free MAO calculator does that from an address.
Step 3: Find what investors actually paid
This is the comp set most wholesalers skip, and it's the one your buyer is using. Look in the same box for homes that were bought as is by an investor. The signs:
- The price was well under the neighborhood's renovated sales.
- The buyer is an LLC, a trust or a company, not a person's name.
- No mortgage was recorded, which usually means cash.
- The home was resold or listed for rent within months. Those are the flips that become your ARV comps, which means their purchase prices are your buyer price comps.
- The sale never hit the MLS. Off-market sales in the public record are often wholesale deals.
Match condition carefully. A fire-damaged teardown that sold cheap is not a comp for a dated house that needs a normal rehab, but it is a floor: if investors paid that much per square foot for a burned-out house, they'll pay more for yours.
Use the recorded price as it is. When an investor bought through an assignment, the wholesaler's fee may not show in the recorded price, so the buyer's real basis can be a little higher. Note it and move on.
Now take the price per square foot of those investor buys and multiply it by your square footage. That's the buyer price.
Double closes: two prices on one house
A double close leaves two recorded sales close together: the wholesaler buying from the seller, then selling to the investor. When you find one in your comps:
- The second price is what the investor paid. That's your buyer price comp.
- The gap between the two is the spread that wholesaler made. It tells you what fees your market supports.
Most sold histories show you one price per house. Checking the deed history on any home that sold twice in a short window is how you spot them; the guide to seeing what an investor paid walks through reading the deeds. The assignment clause guide covers when to assign and when to double close yourself.
A worked example
Say you're pricing a 3 bed, 2 bath, 1,450 square foot house that needs paint, flooring and a kitchen refresh.
ARV comps. Three renovated homes within a mile resold for $229,000, $236,000 and $241,000 in the last year. Your house has no garage and one of the comps does, so you lean to the middle: ARV about $235,000.
70% rule. Repairs come to about $25,000. 70% of $235,000 is $164,500, minus $25,000 is $139,500.
Investor buys. Three homes like yours, in similar shape, were bought by LLCs for $138,000, $141,000 and $146,000. That's about $95 to $100 a square foot, or $138,000 to $145,000 for your 1,450 square feet.
The two methods agree: a cash buyer pays about $140,000 for this house. If you want a $10,000 fee, your highest offer to the seller is about $130,000. If the seller won't go under $135,000, you could make up to $5,000, or you pass.
| Step | Number |
|---|---|
| ARV from renovated resales | $235,000 |
| 70% of ARV minus $25,000 repairs | $139,500 |
| Investor buys, about $95 to $100 a square foot | $138,000 to $145,000 |
| Buyer price | about $140,000 |
| Your fee | $10,000 |
| Highest offer to the seller | about $130,000 |
Every comp is a buyer
Here's the part that pays twice. Each investor purchase in your buyer price comps is a cash buyer who bought a house like yours, near your deal, in the last year. That's a better buyer list than one you can buy.
Look up who's behind each LLC in your state's business entity search or the county records, and reach out when you have the contract. Buyers who already own on that street often move fastest. The guide to finding cash buyers near a property walks through the lookup and who to call first.
From the number to the offer
Once the number is set, the work is sending a real offer on the state contract before someone else does. The guide to wholesaling MLS properties covers picking listings, and the offers per deal guide shows how many to send.
I built SendMLS for the sending part: type an address, it fills your state's purchase contract from county records and the listing, and sends the signed offer to the listing agent from your own Gmail with proof of funds and open tracking. We're also building a browser extension that shows what investors paid nearby, double closes included, right on the listing page; the wholesale comps early access list is open.
- Propertyaddress
- Filled stateapproved contract
- Listing agentinbox
- Presentedto the seller
FAQ
How do you comp a wholesale deal?
Comp it twice. Find the ARV from renovated homes that resold within about a mile in the last 12 months, then find what investors paid for similar homes in similar condition in the same area. Take 70% of the ARV minus repairs, check it against the investor purchase prices, and subtract your fee to get your highest offer.
What percentage of ARV do cash buyers pay?
The common rule is 70% of ARV minus repairs. In practice it depends on the market, so check it against what investors actually paid per square foot for similar homes nearby in the last year. Those purchases are the most direct answer for your street.
How far back and how far away should wholesale comps be?
Within about a mile and from the last 12 months is the best range. Past 2 miles or two years, the comps describe a different neighborhood or a different market. Widen the time window before you widen the distance.
How do I know a sale was an investor purchase?
Look for a price well under the neighborhood's renovated sales, a buyer that is an LLC, trust or company, no recorded mortgage, a sale that never hit the MLS, or a home that was resold or rented within months.
What is a double close in comps?
Two recorded sales of the same house close together: the wholesaler buying from the seller, then selling to the investor. The second price is what the investor paid, and the gap between the two shows the fee that wholesaler made.
Send your next ten offers by lunch
A good comp is only worth something once it turns into a signed offer. Start a free 7-day trial of SendMLS: type an address, it fills your state's purchase contract, and sends it from your own Gmail with proof of funds and open tracking. Or see how it works first.